Recent commentary from fans and wrestling insiders suggests that WWE SmackDown, once seen as the more dynamic and exciting of WWE’s weekly shows, has lost its edge — and many are now blaming the creative decisions under Triple H’s leadership for the downturn. Critics argue that the current product feels stagnant, predictable, and lacking impact, especially compared to earlier eras.
One major point of contention is the lack of compelling storytelling and meaningful character moments that once helped SmackDown stand out. Fans and commentators have increasingly voiced frustration with how matches end and how story arcs are structured, believing many segments feel rehearsed rather than organic — a trend some attribute to scripted promos and overly rigid creative planning.
Social media reactions also show growing dissatisfaction. Some fans have gone as far as blaming Triple H directly, saying his booking choices have slowed pacing, diluted crowd engagement, and muted excitement during key moments. One recent fan comment summed up this sentiment, suggesting WWE “fumbled” major opportunities and lamenting that Triple H’s creative vision hasn’t lived up to expectations this year.
Critics aren’t just limited to fans: veteran commentators have publicly criticized the creative team’s direction. They note that SmackDown’s identity has at times blurred, with less emphasis on surprise returns, emotional payoffs, or memorable cliffhangers that once defined major episodes. This has created a sense that SmackDown episodes are less appointment-viewing than in years past.
Behind the scenes, WWE’s storytelling challenges have coincided with broader changes in how writing rooms function and how segments are crafted. Some insiders point to a heavier reliance on pre-written scripts that can feel less natural and less reactive to live crowd energy than in previous eras, contributing to the perception that SmackDown has lost its spark.
Despite the criticism, SmackDown continues to feature major matches and high-profile talent, and there are signs the company is experimenting with ways to refocus the brand. Whether this results in a reinvigorated show or simply more debate among fans remains to be seen — but it’s clear the conversation around SmackDown’s direction and Triple H’s role in shaping it is ongoing.